top of page


Hey, remember 2020? The year of Covid-19? The year that Kirsten Fuchs, owner of Baked Pie Company, decided to open a sandwich shop right in the middle of that virus? Some thought she was crazy, but most thought she was on to something. Something that was bigger than the virus, bigger than social distancing and

bigger than a spoonful of peanut butter!

With the help of family and friends and some magic from God himself, Kirsten opened P B & Jay's Café. Named after her father, TJ, this unique café offers quality nut butters, locally made jams and preserves and delicious breads. Anyone missing their childhood? You will find it at the Café!

The Café also offers local coffees roasted from Storehouse Coffee and delicious baked goods from, none other than Baked Pie Company! You will find baked goods that you won't find anywhere else! Join us for breakfast, lunch or an early dinner and see what everyone is raving about!

bottom of page